Incorrect/confusing ordering of transactions
Please see the attached files. This is a distilled down version of something I saw on a larger data set.
- The balance is show at £1000 on 1st July.
- A scheduled transaction for -£20 is shown next, but the balance is somehow £880. I would expect £980 here.
- The next line is a regular transaction for £100. The balance is shown as £900. I would expect £880.
- The next is a scheduled transaction for -£20 again. It the balance looks like it has recovered correctly here.
It looks like transactions 2 & 3 were processed in the opposite order to that shown. In my original case there were many more transactions, so it was harder to work out what was going on.
-
dodgyaddition.png
94.3 KB
-
july12_dodgy.moneyguru
881 Bytes
-
Virgil Dupras- State changed from new to accepted
- Tag set to bug
I can reproduce the error with these steps:
- Open the moneyguru file attached to the ticket.
- Open the "a/c" account.
- Click on the "Date" column to invert the sort order.
- Click on the "Date" column again to bring it back.
The result is that the schedule spawn, which was supposed to be after the regular transaction is now before it.
-
Virgil Dupras
- Assigned user set to Virgil Dupras
-
Virgil Dupras
As I was trying to create an automated test for this, an important detail emerged: For this bug to happen, the document has to be saved and reloaded.
-
Virgil Dupras
Oh, it has nothing to do with save/reload after all, it's just that reloaded transactions have a +1 on their "position" attribute. We can reproduce the problem without reloading if we have 2 transactions and a spawn on the same date.
-
Virgil Dupras
- State changed from accepted to fixed
(from [97dab691a584]) [#328 Incorrect/confusing ordering of transactions state:fixed] Fixed sorting inconsistency in transaction tables when schedule spawns were involved. https://bitbucket.org/hsoft/moneyguru/changeset/97dab691a584/
Please Sign in or create a free account to add a new ticket.
With your very own profile, you can contribute to projects, track your activity, watch tickets, receive and update tickets through your email and much more.